groundviews is a Sri Lankan citizen journalism initiativeregister here.login.find out more
inicio mail me! sindicaci;ón

Language Barriers

When looking at the root causes of the Sri Lankan conflict, one issue that comes up time and time again is language. According to The Constitution, Sri Lanka’s national languages are Sinhala and Tamil but it seems that ‘national language’ and ‘official language’ mean different things. The Constitution has two separate sections for these, the latter of which reads “The official language of Sri Lanka shall be Sinhala. Tamil shall also be an official language. English shall be the link language.” From the wording alone, it is not surprising that this is still a very problematic area where discrimination and inequality prevail.

Today, Sri Lankans have the right to an education in either Sinhala or Tamil, but they are not required to learn both which means that from a very early age, communities are being divided by language barriers. That is not to say that Sri Lankans are monolingual. On the contrary, many Tamil people have learnt Sinhala, especially those living in the Southern province and the majority of the Muslim community is also fluent in both Tamil and Sinhala, as well as English. But the average Singhalese person has neither the need nor the desire to learn Tamil and communicates in either Sinhala or English.

Of course, there are a few exceptions. Dilini Rajapakse is a Singhalese woman and holds a degree in the Sinhala language. But the subject she teaches at the Poramadulla Central College in Hangurankette is an unfamiliar one for the majority of the Sinhalese students. Dilini teaches Tamil from grade six to nine, having pursued her own personal desire to communicate with her Tamil and Muslim peers: “I had an interest in learning Tamil since I was a child. Unfortunately when we were schooling we were not taught Tamil as a second language. I went to the library and learnt the Tamil alphabets by myself. When I was doing so I got the chance to enter the Campus. There we had many Tamil and Muslim friends. We were with them a lot and we also shared our food.”

Teaching Singhalese students to use the Tamil medium potentially has long term and far reaching benefits. As language is such a vital component to a person’s identity, being familiar with different languages will inevitably create more understanding and respect between the different communities that make up the multicultural fabric of Sri Lankan society. However, this cannot be achieved while the education system fails to address this need and furthermore, learning a language from grades six to nine is hardly an adequate period of time for students to grasp sufficient understanding and proficiency.  The lack of trained Tamil teachers has proved to be a problem when addressing this issue and according to Acting Principal of Poramadulla Central College, P.B Rajanayake, this is the reason they recruited a Singhalese Tamil language teacher. “Actually we appointed this Sinhala teacher to teach Tamil because we do not have a Tamil medium teacher. This teacher was not appointed to teach Tamil in this school but knowing that we do not have teachers for Tamil she took the responsibility to teach according to the knowledge she has gained personally. It is a great service for the students of our school.” 

In the past it has also been said that following Independence in 1948 when the education system was reviewed and deliberation was taking place regarding bilingualism in schools, it was decided that the ratio of Sinhala and Tamil medium schools meant that far more Tamil teachers would be given jobs in Sinhala schools than vice versa, so the idea was abandoned.  But today it seems that people are becoming more and more in favour of bilingualism, whether it is for peaceful co-existence or for increased trade potential A survey conducted in 2006 showed that 65.5% of the civilians have strongly agreed that people, especially those working in government organizations, should be fluent in both national languages. But perhaps more importantly, children in schools are showing a genuine interest in learning both languages but unless policies are put in place and teachers are trained, the language barriers that divide this nation will remain firmly in place.
 


535 have read this this article so far. You may also find these articles interesting:
  • Education, Citizenship and Development Siri Hettige Professor of Sociology University of Colombo Education is recognized the world over as a means of achieving wider social and economic objectives. Modern education systems are designed in such a way as to facilitate the achievement of such wider objectives.  On the one hand, we provide  youngsters with a basic education that enables them to... CHA, September 27, 2008
  • Discrimination in Law college entrance? 9 students who sat for Law College entrance examination in academic year 2006/2007-appeal case at Srilankan appeal court today with demanding of to reduce cut off marks from 173 to 160. One of the complainer (H.M.Rifan) spoke to me. “We are fighting for all Tamil medium Students. Every year only one or two Tamil medium... CRep, January 1, 2007

| Share this article on Facebook

Theena said,

April 9, 2007 @ 4:32 pm

I am in favour of a multi-lingual society where all three languages - Sinhala, Tamil and English - are taught from Nursery level to at least Grade 10. The teaching would have to be standardized so that all students, regardless of background, get access to the same level of tri-lingual education; ie a Sinhalease student learns Tamil at the same level as a Tamil student learning the lanuage would, while a Tamil student learns Sinhala at the same level as a Sinhalease of the same age would learn it. The need for a “link language”, played by English since independence, would in time become obsolete.

Hopefully, this is not a dream.

SH said,

April 9, 2007 @ 6:31 pm

Learning these ancient languages for personal enrichment not just for political, or business purposes, is something that is lacking in this country. In fact there are some living in the country, who don’t even bother to learn either language.

JustMal said,

April 9, 2007 @ 8:37 pm

I don’t think there is a necessity for Sinhalese to learn Tamil in Sri Lanka. Sinhala is spoken and understood by over 85% of the population, including - as the writer would agree - a sizable number of Tamils and Moors. It simply is not pragmatic to forcibly teach Tamil to millions of unwilling Sinhalese when most people could effectively and efficiently communicate with each other in Sinhala or English anyway. This is political correctness gone mad on a scale unseen in any other sensible country in the world. The rest of the world is moving away from the bankrupt and failed multi-cultural multi-lingual utopian fantasy of the 20th century and it’s time that Sri Lanka did so too.

Nia said,

April 10, 2007 @ 12:01 pm

JustMal,

If you view language purely as a means of communication then yes, it may well seem pointless for Singhalese people to learn Tamil. But in my opinion, language is a hugely important part of a person’s cultural identity, and so if two people from different ethnic communities understand the other’s language, they are more likely to understand one another generally, helping to break down the “us and them” atmosphere that we have in this country today.
And also, adults may be unwilling to learn a new language but children are generally quite eager and can pick up two or even three additional languages to what they speak at home very easily. The difficult part is putting the education policies in place and making sure there are adequate teachers in all schools all over SL…The actual language learning process is easy.

Theena said,

April 10, 2007 @ 1:03 pm

Mal,

This isn’t Political Correctness or Utopian gone mad. It is simply common sense.

That attitude of yours - that it is not pragmatic to teach Tamil to millions of Sinhalese who can’t, frankly, be bothered - will be replied in kind by LTTE who would never allow for people wanting to learn Sinhala. The longer this attitude persists in both sides, the longer this conflict will continue.

Besides, who is talking about millions of Sinhalese? We are talking about kids - starting with the Nursery level and going all the way up to Grade 10 - from both sides, learning the language. They are the future and the sooner we start with the them, the sooner this country will stop thinking about stupid shit like this – let alone discussing it at various forums, offline and online – and go about reaching it’s undoubted potential.

Besides, what harm is there in letting kids learn a new language? And, deny it all you want, but to kids in Jaffna Sinhala is a new language; their exposure to Sinhala is much less than Sinhalese kids in the South are exposed to Tamil through various media.

Des said,

April 10, 2007 @ 1:22 pm

I disagree Justmal. While your figure of 85% of the population speaking Sinhala and English may or may not be correct. The percentage of Tamil people who don’t speak Sinhala is much higher. My guess is 50%. I would estimate 95% of Sinhalese people don’t speak Tamil.

Anyone got the stats?

I think Sinhalese people would like to speak Tamil and many do. Sinhalese people have to live in this Island with Tamilians, and I for one am trying to learn, and I know some of my friends are too. There are lots of similarities in words and alphabet and grammer and I would rather be able to speak with all people living in this country.

There will also be more ethnic harmony if everyone spoke the other’s language, and less distrust. Wouldn’t you agree on that Justmal?

Niroshan said,

April 10, 2007 @ 2:46 pm

I think the most sensible thing to do is to teach all subjects in English and teach Tamil and Sinhala as a part of the curriculum. This way all students, be it Tamil or Sinhalease can communicate in English while not forgetting their mother tongue and not losing touch with their own culture and customs. Of course it’s easier said than done but, isn’t everything?

SH said,

April 10, 2007 @ 7:15 pm

In Melbourne, Australia, school students are provided an incentive to learn a language other than English.

10 bonus points are added to your University Entrace score if you study another language for your examinations. The only other subject that attracts such a large number of bonus points is specialist Maths (Engineering Maths).
Both Sinhalese and Tamil can be offered as a subject for VCE (Victorian Certificate of Education).

As far as I can recall this incentive was introduced by the Victorian liberal (conservative) government, and is still continued by the Victorian labour government.

This is irrelevant to the above incentive, but the oposition leader of the Australian Labour Party and quite possibly the next Prime Minister Australia, Kevin Rudd, speaks fluent Mandarin and has had an interest in Chinese history and culture from a young age. One could say it is a sign of the times.

(Excuse me if I have double posted. The earlier post does not appear in my browser)

SH said,

April 10, 2007 @ 7:20 pm

In canada, where language is a political issue like Sri Lanka, French is compulsory till a certain level.

ethnichybrid said,

April 24, 2007 @ 5:35 pm

I am glad to see that the majority of the comments are for learning all three languages, or at least two of the languages Sinhala and Tamil. In contrast to JustMal’s chauvinistic attitude towards learning Tamil, most people that I meet in my travels throughout the island have expressed a desire to learn the other language andof course the proliferation of institutes teaching English goes to show that they are desperate to learn English. (Though the reasons for that maybe a whole different debate). It is utter stupidity to resist learning another language. It has all the pluses and no negatives that I know of. There is the exposure to not just another language but literature, culture, philosophy, history etc etc. I place the blame wholly on the successive Sri Lankan governments for not teaching children all three languages. In Holland children are taught many languages which they are fluent in, some of them being, English, French, German and of course Dutch. So why can’t we learn another language that exists in our country and that is realistically speaking so close to our culture as well. I am also appalled that international school going kids would rather learn French or German than the languages of this country.

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

This is a moderated forum. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. You agree not to post comments that are off topic, defamatory, obscene, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy.

Please read our full submission guidelines before you comment.

Comments that do not adhere to these guidelines will be edited or deleted and those who repeatedly abuse this forum will be banned. Thanks in advance for your civil and constructive engagement.

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free