groundviews is a Sri Lankan citizen journalism initiativeregister here.login.find out more
inicio mail me! sindicaci;ón

Arrogance at it’s peak – Expulsion of Tamils from Colombo

“Don’t worry. It’s only those who were not able to prove their identity and those who didn’t have a reason to stay in Colombo who have been evacuated”. This is how a friend who speaks a different language to mine responded to the ouster of 376 Tamils from Colombo on Thursday the 7th of June.

The need to possess a ‘legitimate’ reason to stay in Colombo.
A Tamil is expected to possess a ‘legitimate reason’ to stay in Colombo, which may include attending university, doing a job etc. Otherwise he does not have any business to be in Colombo. Even those who can stay in Colombo are expected to possess sufficient reason to be on the streets. The question “Kohitha Yanne?” strikes at the rock bottom of our freedom and fundamental rights. It wont be acceptable to provide answers in the likes of “off to the beach side to get some fresh air” to this Kohithe Yanne question. That definitely can’t be a ‘good’ reason to be on the streets. Of course the blame shifters will put this on our very own shoulders: “You are responsible. We are helpless as far as you continue to support the LTTE. We are only acting on National Security interests” would be the typical ‘sympathetic’ response.

In a recent forum theatre some of us tried to show how some of the very basic things that ‘normal’ young people would consider as part and parcel of their ‘youthful life’ have to be foregone by young people from the minority communities living in Colombo. Ex: Socialising with peers after 9 pm, spending time at the beach, the freedom to loiter around. I have always experienced a greater sense of freedom when I’m abroad on visits – I have no fear or second thoughts when I walk out on the streets at 12 in the night unlike in Colombo where I would rarely be out after 9 pm. People might want to call this trivial in the wake of the larger issues that loom around us. But these larger issues are a sum total of these trivial issues that we face. And the other way around – the larger issues have resulted in the formation of these trivial issues. In fact it is these trivial day to day issues that determine and help shape the opinion of a person to the larger problems.

The people who have been evacuated.
Most of those who have been evacuated from the lodges I guess are young people. (Though I understand that there were people in their 70s who were among those evacuated). These people (most of whom are my peers in terms of age, ethnicity and place of origin) are in Colombo mostly in search of better education. (Mostly those who have done their Advanced Level Exams and who have qualified for university entrance but left out because there isn’t sufficient space for them in our universities. There are many of them who stay in Colombo to work out their admission to Russia, Belarus (!!!) and Bangladesh(!!!) for medical school entrance. There are others who seek entrance to Indian Colleges.) I know that a lot of my peers stay in Colombo seeking to go abroad, sick of the violence and instability in their lives and in search for a better living. Those who stay in lodges are those who can’t afford a private boarding in the ever increasing CoL in Colombo or those who don’t have relatives or friends who can put them up in their homes. I’m not saying that there are no LTTE carders in disguise in these lodges, probably there are some. But the general profile of people living in the lodges is the above.

The politics
The act of evacuating Tamils from lodges in Colombo shows how the GOSL is emboldened by the International Community’s silence (which is largely because they can’t afford to criticize the Govt in fear of being seen as supporting the LTTE). And of course this is part of the GOSL’s agenda of ‘fighting terrorism’ and hence these foreign governments are worried that people will raise questions of their moral integrity, even if they weakly protest, given their records in Iraq and Afghanistan. This act of barbarism has happened when Akashi the Japanese special envoy is here in Sri Lanka to discuss with different stakeholders about the ‘peace process’.

I was heartened to hear Anadasanagree on Suriyan FM terming this act of arrogance by the GOSL as ‘stupid’. He sounded very angry and was highly critical. He even went to the extent to say “If the armed forces and the police can’t find the real terrorists let them go home. Why are they harassing innocent people? These people have sort refuge due to LTTE atrocities and now they are being subjected to atrocities inflicted by the armed forces. Where do they want us to go? To fall into the sea? If they can push us off into the sea that will be the best thing to do.”. Sangaree needs to do much more than just sending letters and faxes to Mahinda. He must publicly announce that he has lost confidence in the GOSL. His luke warm response to the SLFP proposals should not be repeated. All other minority parties SLMC, NUA, CWC, UPF all should pull out of the govt. I have no doubt though that the only SL Tamil Cabinet Minister will decide to stay on with the Govt.

The ouster and transfer to Vavuniya of those Tamils from lodges in Colombo is one more incident that will now be used by Tamil Nationalists to substantiate the claim that the North and East are the traditional homelands of the Tamil people. The act symbolically says: “That is where you are supposed to be. Not here”. I wonder what people like HL De Silva who seek to negate the homeland theory by advocating the ‘feel good’ philosophy that the whole of Sri Lanka belongs to all people(s) of Sri Lanka have got to say to incidents like this.

What next?

If I say that the police and armed forces will turn next to the people living in private homes and boarding people will tell me that I’m paranoid. They would have said the same if I had written some time back that the govt had plans to evacuate Tamils from lodges. In fact the only way to get Colombo free of terrorists is to evacuate all Tamils from the city. But what about those whom the President himself calls ‘Sinhala Kottiya’ and ‘Muslim Kottiya’? How do we get these people out of the capital?

Print this post
1,447 have read this this article so far. You may also find these articles interesting:
  • An exclusive interview with Eastern Province Chief Minister Pillayan after the TMVP’s arms decommissioning English transcript of an exclusive interview with the Eastern Province Chief Minister Sivanesathurai Chandrakanthan (alias Pillayan) conducted by Vikalpa. Have all the powers in the 13th amendment been given to the Provincial Councils? It is not possible to say that. It should have been implemented fully as soon as it was enacted. Unfortunately, the North Eastern PC... Groundviews, March 9, 2009
  • People Reading Newspaper At Shop In Jaffna A person reading Uthayan newspaper publishing in Jaffna at a newspaper agent shop entrance. Newspaper printing has dropped due to publishers not having permission to send more news print paper from Colombo. One agent pasted the newspaper in his shop entrance the customers come and read the newspaper in the early morning. He said he sold... jafrep, February 2, 2007

| Share this article on Facebook

mohammad said,

June 8, 2007 @ 5:27 am

the entire story is simply a media beat up. show me a journalist who doesn’t get weak at the knees when presented the opportunity to throw around the phrase ‘ethnic cleansing’, and i’ll find you a lawyer who is a habitual truth teller. regardless of the sensationalizing, the facts remain no one who was a) gainfully employed, b) enrolled in an educational facility or c) other compelling circumstances was evicted. furthermore to the point, the people who have been in these lodges have been there for well over 6 months. there are is an abundance of work available in colombo for anyone who wants it, and clearly this group of individuals did not want employment. there was also overwhelming evidence that a number individuals living in these lodges were involved in a variety of anti-social activities.

aadhavan said,

June 8, 2007 @ 6:12 am

This is a comment I made on Ravana’s blog:

The semi ethnic cleansing that occurred today has most right thinking Sri Lankans in a state of depression. “What next?” is the question on our minds. This move is a slap in the face of any movement that believed in integration and reconciliation between the two communities. The thing about Colombo is that it has always had two dimensions to it. On the one hand, it’s the seat of power concentrated in one group and one man, but on the other it has, since the shock of 1983 slowly wore out, been a cosmopolitan hub where even the most extremist politicians like to point out, the racial groups live in relative harmony and peace.

Today’s move is based on a separatist ideology. It is based on the idea that the North and the East are the only places where the Tamils ought to live. It is based on the idea of a Tamil Eelam. It’s based on the idea that Tamils do not have the equal right to live anywhere other than the North and East. It’s based on the idea that Tamils live in Colombo not by right, but by permission. “We’ll let you stay if we want you stay” is what the government seems to be saying, “you have no right to be here unless we want you here.” The only conclusion I can draw is that the government believes in separatism, in division and in the perpetuation of conflict. As a Tamil, I have had to come to terms with the idea that this will never be home. Home is a place you have a ‘right’ to live, not where you are ‘permitted’ to live. I hope the reality changes soon. The separatists won today, and all those who believe in a united and integrated Sri Lanka have just been handed down a severe beating.

ethnichybrid said,

June 8, 2007 @ 6:20 pm

Mohammed I am appalled by your comments. It shows great insensitivity and stupidity to imply that all the Tamils who don’t have a reason to be in Colombo should be sent to where they came from. If we are all full citizens of Sri Lanka we have a right to go where we want, stay where we want and do what we want (within the law of course).Your outrageous remark that a number of those living in lodges were engaged in anti-social activity – first how do you know that? and second if true does not warrant the expulsion of all. Its like all the Muslims to be thrown out of the US of A for 9/11. You have demonstrated to me at least that you are as bad as any Sinhala Chauvinist! And be careful! the next time they will come after you!

John said,

June 8, 2007 @ 10:50 pm

I hope Mohammad has good reasons to be in and around Colombo. I hope he can provide this “overwhelming evidence” for the crimes of these Tamils who are being evicted. If the evidence is so overwhelming, why aren’t they charged with crimes if that is the case instead of being evicted and cattled together to be “deported”. I guess this is the way justice works in Sri lanka (of course democratically elected!!) I guess it’s easy for people who are not affected or gaining from this atrocities to make such comments. Just wait till the days Mulims and Singhalese who don’t agreee with this regime are hurded towards the prison…it’s not long to go for that day!!…

Bishan said,

June 9, 2007 @ 9:29 pm

A few weeks back I was talking to a Sri Lankan Tamil who had grown up in Jaffna. He had suffered during his formative years of education because of the ethnic conflict. After graduation he had worked in a respectable government job in the capital and other parts of the island for several years.

I was interested to hear some of his views on the current political situation in Sri Lanka. In summary, he felt that that he was willing to tolerate the atrocities of the LTTE because at least this movement gave the Tamil people some hope for a land that they could live peacefully. In my opinion he was extreme in his views because he believed in getting Eelam at “all” costs (no matter how much killing was necessary). I asked him why he wanted this fight that will cause much killing and suffering in the process, especially when there was really “no guarantee” that an autonomously run state run by a regime such as the LTTE would ultimately be able to offer a lasting peaceful living to it’s citizens? His answer was because he had “a complete lack of trust” in the government and that the government of Sri Lanka would ever be able to respect Tamils as equal citizens.

I sincerely hope that this person’s worst fears are wrong, and that the government of Sri Lanka and the people of Sri Lanka are capable of respecting all our citizens with the same dignity.

Recent facts go against this. As reported in the papers, police and army officers visited various lodges occupied predominantly by Tamils in Colombo and forcibly removing Tamils from these guesthouses on the 7th of June. This was not only breaching their civil liberties but a huge a step in the opposite direction to creating a sense of trust in the government within the Tamil people, which is so clearly and dearly need to dissolve this conflict.

However, there is glimmer of hope that comes with these recent events. The vigilance of an NGO, centre for policy alternatives, resulted in an interim order that was issued by the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka on the 8th of June 2007 directing the Inspector General of Police (IGP), Defense Secretary Gotabaya Rajapakse and eight other respondents, and preventing them from ordering the eviction of Tamil persons from Colombo.

The reasons for hope here are threefold in that a) there was a group that was ready to protest human rights injustices, or potential injustices, as they occurred b) people from community supported this protest in the form of a petition c) the legal system of the government of Sri Lanka supported the protection of it’s citizens by banning further evictions, within a day of the first events. Finally, the local newspapers have reported these events.

Many criticise human rights activists in this country as causing “sensationalism”, or being against the actions of the government, and not against the actions of the LTTE. Perhaps it appears this way on the surface sometimes. However, in most instances when one considers this more closely, a government is supposed to be a democratically elected body, that is answerable to it’s people.

What should be realised is one human rights violation doesn’t against one group does not negate another human rights violation against another ie. “an eye for an eye and the whole world is blind”.

If you look from a religious perspective, no religion to my knowledge advocates violence. Sri Lanka is a country when people have a strong sense of religion – then why do we not not practice what is preached in the doctrine of these religions when it comes to conflict?

It’s time for a change in people attitudes, and the time is now. Tomorrow may be even more difficult that what today seems like.

This is an invitation for positive ideas towards a peaceful united Sri Lanka, in the face of these current adverse times.

Bishan
Sri Lanka

“Nonviolence is a weapon of the strong” Mahatma Gandhi

“The weak can never forgive. Forgiveness is the attribute of the strong.” Mahatma Gandhi

“Be the change you want to see in the world.” Mahatma Gandhi

“Whenever you have truth it must be given with love, or the message and the messenger will be rejected” Mahatma Gandhi

“Darkness cannot drive out darkness; only light can do that. Hate cannot drive out hate; only love can do that” Martin Luther King, Jr.

jayanta wijeratne said,

June 10, 2007 @ 6:21 pm

I wonder what Mohammad has to say now that some of the individuals living in lodges have been “repatriated” to Colombo.
It was the German Theologian,Martin Niemoller ( in his youth he was an admirer of Hitler) who wrote
First they came for the Jews and I did not speak out as I was not a Jew,
Then they came for the Communists and I did not speak out as I was not a Communist
Then theycame for the trade unionists and I did not speak out as I was not a trade unionist,
Then they came for me and there was
no one left to speak out for me.
It was heartning to see that the CPA was able to get an interim order from the Supreme Court to halt the ethnic cleansing…..so maybe ALL is not lost,yet!!!

JS said,

June 11, 2007 @ 9:18 pm

Thanks Bishan for your comments. And esp. for the quote by Mahatma Gandhi -”“Whenever you have truth it must be given with love, or the message and the messenger will be rejected”

I have been thinking a lot about what makes it possible for Sinhala people who in most areas of their lives seem kind, generous, helpful, caring people but become something else when it comes to the Tamils. People who can and do deny what is happening to the Tamil community in Sri Lanka… who say things like “there is no oppression of Tamils” or “Tamils have no legitimate grievances”, etc., Sometimes I have thought that it might be guilt… that it would be too painful for people to accept and allow into their consciousness what is being done in their name and by a state they identify with as their own… and other times I have thought that perhpas it is because people are so scared that if they were to see with open eyes what goes on around them, they would have to change their believes and perhpas their whole identity would have to undergo a radical shift.. and so for the sake of ease and for the sake of self consistent identity of themselves as ‘good people’ and ’sinhala buddhists’ at the same time, they would rather deny reality or not see what happens around them… And at times, I have been in despair about how to ’speak truth’ in a way that can be heard (without denial, without rejection of the messenger and the message both)… it takes great inner reserves and outside support to be able to have love in ones heart in the face of so much disregard for ones humanity and refusal by the majority to see what is going on in their names and yet, that is what it will take if we are to get people to see and hear the “truth” when that truth is so painful to everyone involved… So, I am glad to be reminded that it will take love along wth truth to be heard/understood. I do believe that when we are heard and are able to hear the “other side”, we might actually be able to co-create a Sri Lanka that is just and inclusive of all her people. How long this will take and what will have to shift in order for this to be possible in the current climate is something I don’t have an answer for… But I am convinced it will have to done by the people (not by waiting for the government or any authority).

Sivan said,

June 12, 2007 @ 11:16 am

I was happy to read various comments with regard to the present situation in Sri Lanka. I am of the opinion that the international hipocracy under the the guise of demaocracy is the cause of the deterioration of the ethnic problem.Various representatives come from different countries with different solutions. But none of them have in their minds the next move, when the Srilankan government do not adhere to their advice. Most of them praise the ‘efforts’ of the government to solve the problem, knowing very well the that the government is deliberately misleading them.The Japanese envoy came to Srilanka for the 14th Time and have promised some aid to the affected people throgh the governmet..How far is he sure that the aid will reach the people?

They speak of the violation of cease fire agreement. What tangible steps have been taken by the international community to get the conditions implimentd?
The behaviour of the internaional community is very simlar to giving a gun to a confirmed muderer and asking n him not to use it.

Sivan

Bishan said,

June 13, 2007 @ 9:49 pm

Dear Sivan

I think the international community will do what they find the easiest to do, and what takes the least effort. If you look at it from Japan’s viewpoint, surely life would be a lot easier for them if the country was going really well in terms of movement towards peace. The outside world will probably support an well constructed peace movement, but they won’t want to create it – that is why, again, i believe it is us, the people, who have to show them the way, and as JS has so nicely emphasized using Gandhi’s quote, this is best done with love.

It may sound a bit hocus pocus, but if the masses on the ground level start showing some compassion towards each other, then perhaps a tangible solution will become more likely and the government will have no option but to follow.

There are so many options if one actually opens their mind and ones heart to achieve this. For example both the Tamil and Sinhalese people have a very rich musical and dance culture. If you talk to most people who are interested in either listening to, or watching, or performing music or dance, you’ll find an interest that spans ethinc lines. So why don’t the Sinhala and Tamil cultures embrace each other more often in cultural shows, organised by each other patronaged by each other, and enjoyed each other.

The same goes for art, and for cuisine – which sinhalese person doesn’t like a really good Tamil curry, and vice versa?

So why doesn’t this happen? Because love for others goes out the window, and pride and hurt come rushing in to replace the empty space – compounding a much more selfish kind of love – love for oneself and for “only” one’s own kind.

JS thanks for your insightful post (inverted comma’s)

“I have been thinking a lot about what makes it possible for Sinhala people who in most areas of their lives seem kind, generous, helpful, caring people but become something else when it comes to the Tamils. People who can and do deny what is happening to the Tamil community in Sri Lanka… who say things like “there is no oppression of Tamils” or “Tamils have no legitimate grievances”, etc., Sometimes I have thought that it might be guilt… that it would be too painful for people to accept and allow into their consciousness what is being done in their name and by a state they identify with as their own…etc

I think it is a combination of the reasons you mention, also, i would add simply “pure ignorance from not wanting to see things from the other persons perspective”. This goes for some Sinhalese, and some Tamil people hand in hand.

Also JS, my answer to your question
“And at times, I have been in despair about how to ’speak truth’ in a way that can be heard (without denial, without rejection of the messenger and the message both)…”

I think the way to speak the truth best is with balance. ie give both sides of a story, and remember not to generalise.

I think whilst I agree what you’ve said about all these flawed view point, which happen to be owned by the Sinhalese Buddhist majority in many cases (or most case even as the case may or may not be), I still believe we shouldn’t “generalise” these views to Sinhalese Buddhist ideaology. Firstly because these views are not the case in all Sinhalese Buddhist, which is not the case, because I myself could use this label, and I do not think this way, and secondly for all the sinhalese buddhist people out there who are also against these things, or slightly against these things, they might not embrace this concept if they feel they are being attacked or insulted.

Don’t worry – I’m not in the slightest bit offended by your comments, and causing offense , but I know that some would be, and this is the dilemma i feel you describe by “(without denial, rejection of the messenger or message both)”. I think it is all about letting the so call moderates – expand on moderation, rather than convert to extremism. That’s not to say that deny the facts. But present more facts in addition.

For example, in the last week i’ve seen some heartning things:-
When talking to a Sinhalese Buddhist police officer in conversation, he relayed to me that he has been posted in all sorts of places in the North. He has been in Vavuniya and Jaffna and Muttur. During the Tsunami effort he worked along side people he knew were LTTE and they got on like friends – he had respect for those poeple on a personal level, despite being at war with them. Similarly, he felt that the Tamil poeple he delt with in Vavuniya “had really brought up their Children well, better than our people” – this is what he said to me in Sinhala in his own words. Now this isn’t an absolute truth in itself – because again this is one man’s impression and a generalisation at that. However what this represents is a Sinhalese Buddhist, in government agency of authority, who is able to say such thing, and have such open minded views.

Similarly today i saw 3 military women near a hospital who were talking to young tamil man and his daughter and playing with her like she was one of their own.

Sometimes the way that the we condemn the police and army in this country (myself at times) is justified, but we must remember that there are good people out there and by generalising our comments and views we are doing them a real disservice!

Bishan

SH said,

June 14, 2007 @ 9:14 am

I have been recently getting the impression that some of those working in the armed forces etc. in the combat zones are more in touch with reality.

Met a Tamil family recently who went on a train-trip to Kandy and discovered to their horror that the man conversing with them through the trip was an army officer stationed in the North/East. However, he straight away sensed their discomfort and made it clear to them that it was just a job for him to feed his family and that he didn’t have any feelings of hatred towards Tamils.

Sivan said,

June 15, 2007 @ 2:00 pm

Individual sinhalese or Tamil being good to each other is nothing new. But how are you going resolve the existing problems. I am of opinion that ther is No leader among the sinhales who has the courage to do the right thing. Unfortunately the so called leaders are actually followers of the masses trying to
satisfy their basic instinct s just to be in power. A few of the political leaders who spoke on behalf the Tamils without fear has been deprived of their seats in parliamennt. In fact Tamils are also responsible, as they very seldom voted for them and encouraged them to to support the Tamil cause. They were very selfish and thought only about their own betterment and supported Either the UNP OR SLFP ( one is no better than the other in their hipocracy)in the south.
thus discouraging the few who genuinly spoke on behalf of the Tamils.
Well it is useless talking about the past Without finding a path to success.
I would suggest that we follow the Canadian Fedaralism as stated by secretary to the foreign minister of Canada. If Canadian aid could be accepted why not their political system? perhaps with adjustment her and there.
Sivan.

SH said,

June 15, 2007 @ 3:21 pm

There are a variety of federal systems that have been considered by both Sinhalese and tamil politicians. The Kandyans were the first to propose a federal system, before the Tamils.

SH said,

June 16, 2007 @ 2:11 pm

Of course the people in power have always been more interested in following not leading.

Death by Snoo Snoo said,

June 16, 2007 @ 4:26 pm

Isn’t it amazing. Here we have Tamils who insist they have a homeland and that the LTTE is their sole representative, and that it’s perfectly just to cleanse the North free of all Sinhalese and Muslims. We are told to recognise the existence of the de facto Tamil state “with its courts and traffic police” and all that, yet we are urged to provide this proudly independent country with daily food rations, electricity and newsprint. We also must allow its citizens to freely travel to our capital and bomb us, yet we are not allowed to go into theirs. When we expel 376 of the 15000 Tamils from the North that were residing in cheap hotels in Colombo that night, we are told it’s ethnic cleansing. How else do you expect the “Sinhala chauvinist” government to protect its people from Tamil suicide bombers. When they want to kick out Sinhalese and Muslims from the North and call it their homeland, Tamils are not Sri Lankans but subjects of sovereign Tamileelam, but when they come to Colombo, they expect the same rights as other Sri Lankans. A tad bit unfair, don’t you think? Haven’t you heard you can’t have the cake and eat it too.

The fact remains that there is a de facto Tamil state in Sri Lanka, and terrorist attacks in Colombo are almost exclusively carried out by “citizens” of this state (let’s forget RLO Sinhala kotiyas). Isn’t it fair then if the government imposes some degree of restriction on these people in order to protect the residents of Colombo. Of course we don’t officially recognise this country, and by all means our government should take it over, but we should at least acknowledge its existence for the time being.

If Israelis can prevent Palestinians from coming into occupied territories, why not Sri Lanka. How about the US army restricting movements of Iraqis in their own country entering restricted “secure” zones. Are we expected to conform to a higher standard of conduct than these developed first world countries? We didn’t even arrest them, simply sent them back to their homeland. If they don’t even want to be Sri Lankans, why do they want to be in Colombo. It’s hard to expect any ordinary Sinhalese to empathise with their plight when we are fully aware of how the Tamils drove aware tens of thousands of Sinhalese from North and East.

SH said,

June 17, 2007 @ 4:39 pm

Snoo Snoo,

You obviously have a pretty bleak view of the future and the potential of Sri Lankans to rise above the kind of examples you have provided.

aadhavan said,

June 19, 2007 @ 8:40 am

“We didn’t even arrest them, simply sent them back to their homeland.”

Of course, there’s the small matter of fundamental rights to all citizens but has snoo snoo accepted the Tamil homeland claim? That’s one of the Thimpu principles accepted. One down, two to go.

Death by Snoo Snoo said,

June 19, 2007 @ 8:10 pm

Certainly aadhavan. Conceding the Northern desert as the homeland of Tamils is a small price to pay, provided no Tamils remain in the Sinhala homeland.

aadhavan said,

June 19, 2007 @ 9:13 pm

Last time I checked, Tamils weren’t clamouring to live in Matara. Colombo is the capital city with a Sinhalese minority, hardly a homeland don’t you think.

Death by Snoo Snoo said,

June 20, 2007 @ 9:39 am

So what then, Colombo is going to be the new capital of Tamileelam? Why stop with Colombo, go for the whole country. Sinhalese can always learn Divehi and swim to Maldives.

Death by Snoo Snoo said,

June 20, 2007 @ 9:40 am

Does the same not apply for the East. Tamils are a minority there as well. Hardly a homeland, wouldn’t you agree?

Death by Snoo Snoo said,

June 20, 2007 @ 9:51 am

And Sinhalese are not a minority in the Colombo district, which has a population of 2.3 million – most of them Sinhalese. There are only 117000 Tamils in the Colombo municipality.

I agree that Tamils can’t live in harmony with Sinhalese, or for that matter anyone else. We must therefore grant them a homeland in the North and all the Tamils living outside the North should be sent to their homeland. No Sinhalese would want to go to the Tamil homeland and no Tamils would be allowed to live in the Sinhala homeland. How great and peaceful would that be!

Mind you aadhavan, this time Gotabaya is not going to provide free buses.

shami17 said,

June 20, 2007 @ 1:07 pm

nationalists, terrorists, racists, pacifists…we seems to have ‘em all. but come on sri lanka, why is there no political party that just stands for being sri lankan and embraces our diversity instead of splitting it down the middle?? if we say that we want peace, we’re deemed to be unpatriotic. if we say we want war, we’re nationalists!! in the mad rush to be sinhala or tamil, we’re forgetting muslim, burgher, c. chetties etc etc and all those sri lankans who are of mixed ethnicity. when are we going to see a party that campaigns for say, the environment, instead of basing everything on ethnicity and religion?

JS said,

June 23, 2007 @ 9:08 pm

Bishan,
Here is my delayed response to your post: I have put your comments in square brackets [ ] and put a short line before and after my current comments to make it clear which are my comments and which are yours. Since you quote some of my previous comments, this might get complicated but I will leave at this and hope for the best:

Bishan said,
[JS thanks for your insightful post (inverted comma’s)]
“I have been thinking a lot about what makes it possible for Sinhala people who in most areas of their lives seem kind, generous, helpful, caring people but become something else when it comes to the Tamils. People who can and do deny what is happening to the Tamil community in Sri Lanka… who say things like “there is no oppression of Tamils” or “Tamils have no legitimate grievances”, etc., Sometimes I have thought that it might be guilt… that it would be too painful for people to accept and allow into their consciousness what is being done in their name and by a state they identify with as their own…etc”

[I think it is a combination of the reasons you mention, also, i would add simply “pure ignorance from not wanting to see things from the other persons perspective”. This goes for some Sinhalese, and some Tamil people hand in hand.]
____
I agree this is something both Tamils and Sinhalese (and pretty much all people I have come across in fact) have difficulty with this… and the sad truth is (I believe at least) that all of us human beings are yearning to be understood and seen from our perspective and yet so few people are able to give this to each other…
____

[Also JS, my answer to your question]
“And at times, I have been in despair about how to ’speak truth’ in a way that can be heard (without denial, without rejection of the messenger and the message both)…”
[I think the way to speak the truth best is with balance. ie give both sides of a story, and remember not to generalise.]

____
Thanks for this… I am aware that generalizing is definitely a problem… I think I do this sometimes when I am in pain/despair and sometimes when I am not clear in my thinking… and I do know the damage this does… and it leads to such unnecessary pain (people feeling not seen for who they really are, etc.,). So I am glad to be reminded of this…
____

[I think whilst I agree what you’ve said about all these flawed view point, which happen to be owned by the Sinhalese Buddhist majority in many cases (or most case even as the case may or may not be), I still believe we shouldn’t “generalise” these views to Sinhalese Buddhist ideaology. Firstly because these views are not the case in all Sinhalese Buddhist, which is not the case, because I myself could use this label, and I do not think this way, and secondly for all the sinhalese buddhist people out there who are also against these things, or slightly against these things, they might not embrace this concept if they feel they are being attacked or insulted.]

____
Yes, this is the other problem with generalizing… putting people into camps based on a label or category… I don’t like it when its done to me and I regret doing it to others… in a sense, this is the intellectual equivalent of putting all Tamils into buses and sending them off to the North east simply because they are Tamil and stay in lodges… (which is an extension of generalizing “Tamil speaking people” to mean “LTTE” or “potential LTTE” or “dangerous”, etc.,) It all begins in our minds, in how we label and categorize people instead of seeing them fully human. Our thinking determines our actions after all. So, I want to apologize for generalizing about “Sinhala people” and therefore not seeing you who think differently than what I outlined above.
____

A quote I found online which speaks aptly to this discussion:
“Run your fingers through my soul. For once, just once, feel exactly what I feel, believe what I believe, perceive as I perceive, look, experience, examine, and for once; just once, understand.” – Anonomoys

And another on to follow Gandhi’s quote which initiated this discussion in the first place:
“Eventually you will come to understand that love heals everything, and love is all there is.” Gary Zukav (American author)

Kapila Tissera said,

June 25, 2007 @ 7:10 am

Tamil eviction on Rueters:
Sri Lanka apologises for evictions
http://cosmos.bcst.yahoo.com/up/player/popup/index.php?cl=3003103

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

This is a moderated forum. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. Please do not post comments that are off topic, defamatory, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Comments are automatically scanned for spam and obscenity.

Comments are only approved if they are in line with the site guidelines. Those that do not will be edited or deleted without prior intimation. Comment approval may take up to 24 hours.

Thanks in advance for your civil and constructive engagement.

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free