groundviews is a Sri Lankan citizen journalism initiativeregister here.login.find out more
inicio mail me! sindicaci;ón

An “unpatriotic” appeal for a UN mechanism to protect civilians

These are difficult times for all.

The GoSL is fighting a humanitarian war to liberate innocent civilians from the scourge of man-eating Tigers and claims that the safety and welfare of these “innocent civilians” is foremost in its agenda. The UN claims that the GoSL is cooperating with it, and vice versa. (Atleast that’s what it seems to some of us, as the majority are deafened by the roar of Lions and unable to hear anything else but the roaring)

INGOs are being approached by the GoSL to help with the problem of vast numbers of internally displaced persons (IDPs). However, to quote a helpless INGO worker, “this is a Catch22 – total loose-loose situation…. Us humanitarian organisations have been put up for a huge dilemma; do we support the IDPs coming out from Vanni on the GoSL’s terms, or let them go without support? Do we let ourselves be co-opted, or let the IDPs suffer more?”

Report after report speaks of “liberated” people tucked away safely in camps, unable to leave and settle in a place of their choosing, or reunite with their loved ones. Visitors have to be given special clearance by the MoD to visit them. Those unwittingly involved in this mini-drama claim that even food, clothing, medicines and other essentials which have been collected for these people are not allowed to reach them, as they are denied MoD clearance.

To quote an activist, “From the information we are getting, this is an accurate situation, but NO ONE is willing to go on record today.”

A journalist warns of “possible repercussions (of commenting on the situation). “Understand that there are people on the ground working with the authorities to get the best possible deal for the IDPs, under very trying circumstances. Most of the security personnel on the ground have been accommodating and are bending the rules in order to accommodate help coming from outside. Remember that they too are working according to the orders of the country’s highest authorities” he cautions.

“The situation is far from ideal. But emotional, irresponsible and one-sided articles (like the one by ‘Sri Lankan diary’ in Groundviews) can make the ground situation worse…. if the IDPs are foremost in our mind then we must first understand that for better or worse they are under military control now – and we don’t want to make things worse for them by antagonizing the military…”

But given that it is human beings and not wildlife that is involved in this issue, emotions cannot be put aside so easily. As one INGO worker laments, “it is awful to be aware of the ongoing slaughter, and not be able to do anything to stop it…. In my dreams I hope for an international intervention, but that is not going to happen”.

So in these trying times, we, the people of Sri Lanka, continue our “unpatriotic” appeal for a UN mechanism to provide security for the survivors of this humanitarian war. At the risk of being accused of crying “wolf!” too often, we reiterate what those trapped in their dilemma are afraid to voice – “we do not think it would be wise to leave the protection of the civilians to the authorities!”

Will anyone heed the cry?

Print this post
853 have read this this article so far. You may also find these articles interesting:
  • Breaking News: IDPs in Zone 3 and 4 in Menik Camp affected by flooding Reports received by Groundviews this evening indicate that torrential rains in Vavuniya throughout the day have severely affected IDPs interned in Menik Camp, particularly in Zone 3 and Zone 4. Other unconfirmed reports put the number of those affected by the rains at 15,000 at the time of writing. As early as May this year, serious... Groundviews, August 14, 2009
  • Vaharai starves – International Community is Silent FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: Vaharai starves – International Community is Silent “We only have enough food for one or two more days,” said TRO Vaharai Director of Operations Mr. Moorthy in a telephone message from Vaharai. “The people are suffering and there is nothing that we can do due to the SLA embargo on food and medicine.” The... Arjunan, January 5, 2007

| Share this article on Facebook

N. Ethirveerasingam said,

February 23, 2009 @ 7:17 am

Ange,
No one in Sri Lanka has any power to intervene against the power of the GoSL military machine. No one has marched on behalf of the Tamil civilians in distress in Colombo or elsewhere in Sri Lanka. They, the Tamils, Sinhalese and the Muslims, know the consequences. The international community, including the Co-Chairs have their own agenda and the Tamil civilians in the Vanni and in the Internment Camps in Vavuniya are their pawns.
My fear is what the next three years of misery will bring to the Tamil and Sinhala communities. What will become of the Vanni, Jaffna, and the East. The politico-military apparatus of the Rajapakse family rule may continue for another 20 years. I will leave it to the imagination of the political and military pundits to pontificate on the future.

Gamarala said,

February 24, 2009 @ 12:52 am

Did the Tamil brothers had the power to talk against the LTTE at any time? When the LTTE was winning the war, did you protest against their atrocities? When they were killing innocent civilians, Sinhalese, Tamil and Muslim, did you shout out loud? This is sheer hypocrisy.
On many occasions in the past, the GoSL had to withdraw from the battle front due to the international pressure. Historically, the only time LTTE ask for a truce was when they were loosing. During the peace talks they re-grouped and strengthened their position. This has happened on numerous occasions but not any longer. The lessons have been learned.

When the war is over, we shall be magnanimous in our victory. All the Sinhalese shall rally around the Tamil brothers and help them as much as they could, as they did in the past. Never again shall we allow our Tamil, Muslim and brethren from other minority groups feel insecure.

'I have a dream that Sri Lanka will rise up and live out the true meaning of its creed: that all men are created equal.
I have a dream that the children of Sri Lanka will be able to sit down together at the table of brotherhood.
I have a dream that the children of Sri Lanka will roam from Point Pedro to Dondra Head, without any fear of persecution.'
Let us all do our share to realize this dream.

thilak said,

February 24, 2009 @ 3:33 am

N. Ethirveerasingam -"civilians in distress in Colombo " you must be meaning the tamils going to cima or tution classes, watching the latest tamils films listening to sakthi fm (rather than voice of tigers) and the kovil wel carts around wallawatta,… is that distress… i see only happy smiles…

are you living in colombo or in wanni or in toronto?

Ange said,

February 24, 2009 @ 7:31 am

I am sorry you feel that this is all hypocrisy. I guess we are conditioned to feel comfortable in what we are familiar with.

Doubtless, there are atrocities committed on both sides. But I can't deny the fact that the LTTE has also done a whole lot of good, like training civillians to defend themselves when they are attacked, including digging bunkers for them to hide in during airstrikes, ensuring they have food and essentials (even if it has been robbed from army supplies), funding the care of widows and orphans (even if that meant having a steady supply of recruits from among them), ensuring that children were able to study despite the unrest, and seeing to the welfare of those affected by the tsunami, not to mention the encouragement of a situation free of crime and effective public service during times of peace.

In fact whenever there is a bomb blast in the South, I can't help wonder why they would allow all their good work go to waste with such terrible acts.

I am sorry if you think that makes me an LTTE supporter. I am sure when the atrocities committed hits close to home, I will not be able to see the good.

But until then, I can only see the lack of any effort on the part of the successive GoSLs to do anything that has ensured the safety of Tamil people. As a person who has lived all my life in the South, and had my own family members taken out of their homes and hauled to police stations in their underwear for "interrogation" (despite not having lived their entire lives in Kandy), and having travelled to Jaffna and seen and heard firsthand how members of the armed forces, together with those of the TMVP and EPDP are abusing their power, I agree with Mr. Ethirveerasingam that in this war, the people are just pawns. Be they the Sinhalese youth who are fed tales of patriotism and heroism, or the Tamils who are promised a better tomorrow, or Muslims who are forced to take sides.

Thank you for your wish. I sincerely hope the future generations of Sri Lanka will be able to see such a future. My own recollections are far from that and after having seen my mother struggle to keep us safe during two riots and ever since then, sadly, I have no wish to bring up children in SL. And I hope those who do, be they Sinhalese, Muslim or Tamil, will not have created a climate where they cannot hold the authorities accountable for their actions.

Ange said,

February 24, 2009 @ 8:27 am

You know, call me stupid, but I wonder why noone is marching. What are we afraid of? How is that going to solve anything? We might not be able to stop what is happening (god knows who can) but atleast we can let the world know that we are not in agreement of what is happening. And if we are attacked, well, then atleast no one can say we cry "wolf?" for no reason!

the optimist said,

February 24, 2009 @ 9:51 am

the difference is my friend that the LTTE is a terrorist organisation and the GoSL is an democratically elected government. i see a deference in the way the two are supposed to behave. i'm sorry if you don't.

N. Ethirveerasingam said,

February 24, 2009 @ 10:29 pm

Thilak,
I have spent a lot of time in Colombo and other parts of Sri Lanka each year since 1994 till 2007. You see the surface of the Tamil communities lives. I go in depth by interacting with them. There is a saying in Tamil which in English is,"What you see is not the truth. What you hear is not the truth. The truth is what you arrive at after investigating, analysing and understanding the events." Under the present conditions in Sri Lanka, no one will readily speak what they feel. The link for an HRW video may help you.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JugborcOxjE
You may also want to read the US Senate Foreign Relations Committee hearing held Feb 24. It will give you some perspective of three independent observers.

thilak said,

February 25, 2009 @ 4:39 am

there is also a saying "you see only what you want to see""…
so if you go deep and speak to one person, his view is not the consensus…

so you are now out of SL?

RSS feed for comments on this post · TrackBack URI

Leave a Comment

This is a moderated forum. Comments are the sole responsibility of the person posting them. Please do not post comments that are off topic, defamatory, abusive, threatening or an invasion of privacy. Comments are automatically scanned for spam and obscenity.

Comments are only approved if they are in line with the site guidelines. Those that do not will be edited or deleted without prior intimation. Comment approval may take up to 24 hours.

Thanks in advance for your civil and constructive engagement.

Spam protection by WP Captcha-Free